Tomys Garage Door logo

Is it Better to Buy a New Garage Door or Repair the Old One?

When it comes to maintaining a home, the garage door is an essential yet often overlooked component. It’s a question that many homeowners face: should you buy a new garage door or repair the old one? This decision can be challenging, with various factors to consider. In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both options to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Basics of Garage Door Maintenance

Before diving into the decision-making process, it’s important to understand the basics of garage door maintenance. Regular maintenance is key to prolonging the life of your garage door. This includes checking the balance, lubricating moving parts, and inspecting for wear and tear.

Comparing New Garage Door Installation vs. Repair

Let’s break down the considerations into a detailed table, comparing the aspects of buying a new garage door versus repairing the old one.

Criteria New Garage Door Repairing Old Garage Door
Cost Higher initial investment Lower initial cost
Latest Technology Access to modern features Limited to existing technology
Energy Efficiency Better insulation and energy savings Depends on the condition and age
Aesthetics and Design Wide range of modern designs Limited to current design
Safety and Security Enhanced safety features Existing safety level maintained or improved
Longevity Longer lifespan with new installation Depends on the age and condition
Warranty New warranty coverage Limited or no warranty
Value to Home Can increase home value Maintains current value
Time and Convenience May take time to select and install Usually quicker to repair
Personal Preferences Customization options Limited by current structure

When to Consider a New Garage Door

Increasing Home Value

A new garage door can enhance your home’s curb appeal and value. Modern designs and features can significantly improve the aesthetics of your home.

Safety and Security

Advancements in technology offer better safety and security features in new garage doors. This is crucial for protecting your home and family.

Energy Efficiency

Newer models are often more energy-efficient. They provide better insulation, reducing energy costs in the long run.

When Repair Might Be the Better Choice


Repairing an existing door is often more affordable than replacing it. This is especially true for minor issues.

Historical or Unique Doors

If your garage door has unique features or historical value, repairing might be preferable to maintain its originality.

Less Time-Consuming

Repairs can usually be done quicker than a complete replacement. This is important if you need a functional garage door immediately.

Why Choose Tomys Garage Door

At Tomys Garage Door, we understand the importance of a reliable and aesthetically pleasing garage door. Our experienced team is committed to providing top-notch services. We offer a range of services, from repair to new installations. With us, you get quality, reliability, and customer-centric services tailored to your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to install a new garage door?

Installation Time Frame

The time to install a new garage door varies. It typically takes a day. However, custom designs may take longer. Learn more about the installation process.

Can I install a garage door myself?

DIY vs. Professional Installation

Installing a garage door can be complex. For safety and quality, professional installation is recommended. DIY can lead to issues. Read about DIY risks.

How often should I maintain my garage door?

Maintenance Frequency

Regular maintenance is crucial. It’s recommended to check your garage door bi-annually. This includes lubrication and checking for wear and tear. Discover more on maintenance tips.

Can I add modern features to my old garage door?

Upgrading Old Doors

Yes, certain features can be added. This includes keypad installation and weather stripping. However, some limitations exist depending on the door’s model and age. For details on upgrades, visit garage door keypad installation.


Whether to buy a new garage door or repair the old one depends on various factors. Consider aspects like cost, safety, and aesthetics. Tomys Garage Door offers both new installations and repairs with expertise and care. We ensure your garage door is not only functional but also adds value to your home. For reliable garage door solutions, contact us today. Let us help you make the right choice for your home.

Table of Contents